Skip to Content

How To Make Compost For Your Garden And Enjoy A Bountiful Harvest

Garden compost can be made from kitchen vegetable scraps and lawn debris. It’s not complicated to learn how to make compost for your garden. But turning kitchen waste into good, rich soil improver is not an overnight process.

A handful of fresh compost

How To Make Compost For Your Garden

How to Build, Maintain, and Use a Compost System Secrets and Techniques You Need to Know to Grow the Best Vegetables

Making compost for your garden is not hard, but learning how to make it the right way is important.

What to put in your garden composter

First, like anything, the quality of what you put into your composting pile affects what you get out.

If you want your compost to be organic, it is essential that you put only organic material in.

Kitchen Scraps are good for composting (you can assign this to your children, so they can participate in gardening with you). However, unless you use only organic ingredients in your meals, your purchased produce will be a problem. Any non-organic material added to the garden composter in the form of kitchen scraps would contaminate your compost. It’s recommended to leave animal products out of the mix.

Leaf mold makes a rich compost that would usually be free from chemicals. One challenge is that it takes a long time to make a substantial amount of this organic mulch.

How to use leaf mold to make fertilizer

A simple leaf mold composter can be made by wrapping chicken wire around four posts, creating a bin in between.

If you collect leaves with a lawnmower, the action of the mower will help to break down the leaves. Store the broken-down leaves in the leaf mold composter until you need them.

But even when the leaves are cut up in this way, it will still take about two years to finish. Nevertheless, after a year, you can use the leaves as mulch.

You could also use leaves as the brown ingredient (more on this later) for hot organic compost.

If you have a lot of trees and want to use composting to dispose of the leaves, this is not your best solution. There would be too many leaves for a hot pile to process.

But if you are lucky enough to have an old broadleaf forest on your land, instead of going to all the bother of making organic matter, you can simply harvest decomposed leaf mold from the forest floor. That’s some of the best leaf mulch you could get.

Assuming you don’t have access to a good forest, let’s get back to making your own compost.

Learn more about composting:

Here are some more tips for making your own compost from weeds.

How to compost with worms

Trench composting

What is hot composting?

Vegetable garden composting is the ideal way to convert garden and kitchen waste into nutrient-rich food for the soil. Hot composting is an effective way to quickly decompose these materials.

A hot compost efficiently employs the use of microbes to help break waste material down. You don’t need to add bacteria or microbes to your garden composter; they come free with any materials you use. The action of the microbes speeds up the process.

To compost waste material we need to provide certain conditions. In order to make full use of a bacteria hot composter, your garden bin needs three things:

  1. waste material to process
  2. moisture
  3. oxygen

How to make hot vegetable garden compost

Compost bin

In a hot vegetable garden compost system, you divide up the material into green and brown waste. When there is enough to fill the composting container, assemble the system ensuring there is air and moisture in the right quantities throughout the mix.

If you are going to make a hot compost bed, you will need more than one area. Since you need to turn the compost over every 12 or so weeks, you should ideally use 3 bins for your compost.

Take a look at this page to see how to make a rotating compost drum.

Green material is softer green-leaved plants that rot down quickly. It includes items such as:

  • salad leaves
  • grass cuttings
  • young plants
  • it also includes activators such as the readily available weeds, comfrey, and nettles

The browns consist of tougher plant materials such as:

  • brassica stalks (bashed with a hammer)
  • hedge clippings
  • leaves
  • vegetable peelings

The trouble with creating a hot vegetable compost is that there is usually an imbalance of too many greens to browns, which can make the mix too wet. To counter this, you can add cardboard and shredded paper to the brown items.

How to hot compost

Hot composting system
Once you have enough material to fill your chosen container, follow these three steps:

  1. split all the materials into greens and browns, chopping or shredding any big material and soaking anything that is dry
  2. mix everything together making sure that the drier, tougher items are mixed evenly with the softer, wet materials
  3. then fill the compost bin and cover it

It will only take a few days for the middle of the vegetable garden compost to become hot. If the weather is cold, you’ll likely see some steam coming out. This is a sign that microbes are at work, breaking down waste material.

In a few weeks, the materials will cool as the microbes get short of oxygen and possibly water. When this happens, empty the bin, remix, and water any dry parts before putting the materials back in the composter.

The hot compost should reheat, although it may not get as hot as the first time.

When it cools once more, you may want to turn it a second time. This slowing down is inevitable as the decomposing action moves to tougher ingredients. And as it cools, beetles and worms move in to help.

After about 12 weeks or so, you should have a dark and nutritious homemade soil improver.

If you’d rather take the lazy man’s way to composting, consider cold composting.

Using the cold composting method

The cold composting method is probably the easiest way of making compost. It is usually done throughout the entire year, adding waste materials as and when they become available.

Compost bins are the most common way of making compost and are usually associated with the cold method of composting kitchen and garden waste. You can make your own, or buy one.

A composter can come in many different shapes and sizes: from homemade bins to plastic conical-shaped containers, to tumblers and worm beds. And they all have their different suitability in the garden.

A standard compost bin that uses a cold system also uses bacteria to help the debris decompose. But because we introduce new waste willy-nilly (or without a specific plan), we can’t make full use of the bacteria as we can with hot composting. That’s because this method stifles oxygen or starves moisture from the system, which slows the process.

On the other hand, cold garden compost is easier to make than a hot composter. If you are looking for a faster progression without a lot of trouble, try a tumbler or rotator and add a worm bedding (wormery) because it can take care of more difficult kitchen waste.

The most common way to cold compost uses a conical-shaped compost bin that is usually available in most municipalities.

A cold system does not have to be confined to plastic bins. Any container with an open bottom for drainage can be used.

Let’s talk about how to make a compost bin at home. It’s pretty simple, really. There is nothing better than four upright pallets nailed together to form a box with an open bottom and top and an old bit of carpet as a lid.

How To Make A Compost Bin

Upside down bins for making compost

In larger gardens you may want to use three bins, using the cold composting method for these bins. If you’ve got lots of debris and kitchen scraps, you can move from one bin to another to help speed the process. As the material decomposes, you combine the bins.

The small amount of composted material that results in the third bin is actually the contents of two full bins of raw material, so you can see that the breakdown is quite dramatic.

Avoid putting tap root weeds, rhizome, and tuber root-type plants into a cold composter as they will start to grow. Even a raw potato from the kitchen will start to grow in the spring.

Purchase a rotating composter

It is sometimes said that the fastest way to make compost is the use of a tumbling or rotating compost maker.

EJWOX Garden Compost Bin Tumbler, 43 Gallon Capacity with 2 Chambers Dual Rotating Composting TumblerEJWOX Garden Compost Bin Tumbler, 43 Gallon Capacity with 2 Chambers Dual Rotating Composting TumblerAmazon buy buttonDual Chamber Compost TumblerMiracle Gro Dual Chamber Compost Tumbler – Outdoor Bin with Easy-Turn System, 2 Sliding Doors, Sturdy Steel Frame, BPA-Free Amazon buy button

Some manufacturers will state that when using the right mix of material, at the right moisture and the right temperature, it takes about three weeks to make compost.

To test this claim, Which Magazine tried a number of tumbling composters, comparing them against a hot composting bin. The testers turned the tumblers three times a week and mixed the bin with a fork once a week. It took ten weeks to create compost in the hot compost bin, and on average a month longer in the tumblers.

Although the test is valid, realistically, how many people would manually turn their compost bin every week? Without turning the compost weekly, hot compost would normally take six months.

I could easily see gardeners turning a rotating composter three times a week. If you use one and turn it three times a week, it’s possible to get a good soil improver in about 22-25 weeks.

To create compost, you need heat, oxygen, and moisture. Because the tumbler keeps all of these things in balance, as long as you have the right mix of decaying materials, it would be difficult to get it wrong.

These bins also do a few other things:

  • keep odors down
  • lock your waste away from rodents
  • more importantly, they allow you to mix the contents regularly

So rotating composters are definitely worth investigating.

What to add to your cold composter

To make compost using a cold composter you would add to your bin a good mix (about equal amounts) of green and brown material. Include vegetable kitchen waste, a limited amount of grass clippings, paper, cardboard, tea leaves, coffee grounds, annual weeds, pet rabbit bedding such as hay and droppings, nettles, shredded wood, comfrey, and even old wool.

Add this material as it becomes available and leave it in until everything has decomposed and looks like dark soil. This should take about a year to complete.

Where to buy cold compost bins

Compost Tumbler Bin Composter Dual Chamber 43 Gallon (Bundled with Pearson's Gardening Gloves)

Bins should be available from your local municipality for under $20 and they usually are conical-shaped bins with bottom access.

If you fill a bin, after about six months, you could use the front access panel to get at the bottom of the fertilized material, while still adding material to the top.

Alternatively, you could fill the bin and just leave it for about a year. By then it should resemble potting soil that could be added to your vegetable garden.

Another option would be to fill the bin with vegetable material and once full, slide the bin off the compost, cover it with a plastic sheet, and relocate the bin so you can add more waste.

If your municipality doesn’t offer a compost bin, or you prefer a different kind, remember that compost bins come in all shapes and sizes.

Buy your cold composting bin from Amazon – there are lots to choose from! You’re bound to find one that you like.

Or make your own.

Knowing how to make compost is imperative for any serious gardener. It’s not hard, but it takes some learning to figure out what works best for you.

Compost bins and finished compost in someone\'s hands

Pin To Save For Later

How To Clean Flower Beds In The Fall

Tuesday 1st of November 2022

[…] and any other organic matter that have fallen off nearby trees and bushes and throw them into your compost bin. In the spring, you’ll have some fresh, nutritious compost for your new […]

Best Compost To Buy For Vegetable Garden

Sunday 15th of May 2022

[…] vegetable garden needs a dose of rich, nutritious compost. While it’s best to make your own compost, sometimes it’s just not possible. So today we’ll look at the best compost to buy for […]

How To Grow Beautiful Roses - 10 Tips For Success (Pictures Too!)

Sunday 26th of December 2021

[…] good rule of thumb is to use equal parts compost (homemade or bagged) and soil when preparing new beds for planting roses. This ensures that there […]

How To Celebrate Learn About Composting Day On May 29

Thursday 27th of May 2021

[…] Start a compost pile or bin in your backyard, or a worm bin in your home. It’s actually pretty easy — keep reading to learn more! […]

Topsoil Vs Compost - Which One Should You Use?

Tuesday 16th of March 2021

[…] topsoil, you can choose to make your own compost. This is a great low-cost (free!) option if you don’t need it right away, though of course if […]