They might look cute at the nursery, but some trees bring more trouble than they’re worth. Weak branches, root systems that lift sidewalks, and nonstop leaf litter are just the beginning. A tree that seems perfect in a pot can quickly turn into a yard-sized problem once it matures. Some trees may look appealing when young but are known for being messy, destructive, or challenging to manage in a typical yard.
Before planting anything large, it’s worth thinking through how it will behave when fully grown—how wide it spreads, how much cleanup it adds, and if it plays well with your lawn, foundation, or neighbors. A good-looking tree today can become a source of surprise repair bills, unwanted pests, or endless raking later.
Knowing what to consider before planting a tree is crucial. Here are some trees that you may need to take a second thought before digging that hole.
1. Silver Maple
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Silver maples grow fast and wide, which sounds great until the branches start cracking during every windstorm. Their wood is soft, brittle, and prone to breaking without warning. That means expensive cleanup, damaged fences, or something worse, like crashing through your roof during a rainy Tuesday. They also send out shallow, greedy roots that lift sidewalks, clog sewer lines, and crowd out other plants. What you gain in speed, you lose in stability. This is the tree version of getting married after the second date, impressive at first, but difficult to live with.
2. Bradford Pear
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Once planted everywhere for their quick growth and spring blooms, Bradford pears have become a national regret. Their branches grow too tightly, creating a weak structure that splits apart once the canopy matures. Whole trees often split in half during storms. They also smell terrible when in bloom, and some describe it as rotting fish. Add in their tendency to cross-pollinate with other pear varieties and spread invasively, and you’re left with a tree that’s both fragile and literally stinky.
3. Weeping Willow
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Weeping willows have undeniable charm, especially near water. But they need constant moisture and space, lots of it. Their roots stretch far and wide, often invading sewer lines, septic systems, and foundation cracks in search of water. Their leaves and twigs fall constantly, making a mess that’s nearly impossible to keep up with. Unless you live on acreage with a natural pond and love raking, this isn’t a tree for suburbia. If you have your heart set on a weeping tree, check all of your options first.
4. Cottonwood
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Cottonwoods grow tall and fast, and that’s where the good news ends. Their roots are aggressive, often buckling driveways and reaching deep into underground pipes. On top of that, they shed cottony fluff that blankets everything in sight. This fluff clogs air conditioning units, sticks to window screens, and can make allergy season feel like a snowstorm. Cottonwoods are better suited to wide open spaces where they can’t do much damage or annoy your neighbors.
5. Black Walnut
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Black walnuts are tough, sturdy trees with a hidden downside: they release a chemical called juglone that’s toxic to many plants. Tomatoes, peppers, azaleas, hydrangeas, and even lawn grass can suffer just by being nearby. The nuts themselves are hard, heavy, and wrapped in a thick husk that stains anything it touches. Cleaning them up is a chore. Unless you’re planning to harvest the nuts and know how to handle the mess, skip this tree.
6. Sweetgum
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Sweetgum trees have a nice symmetrical shape and turn bright colors in the fall. But their fruit—those spiky little balls—drop in huge numbers and are a nightmare underfoot. They’re hard, sharp, and can ruin a mower blade or twist an ankle. Even when the tree is healthy, you’ll be dealing with constant cleanup. Some newer cultivars are fruitless, but if you’re not absolutely sure what you’re buying, you could be signing up for decades of painful lawn debris.
7. Sycamore
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Sycamores are massive shade trees, but they shed like they’re trying to win a contest. Bark peels off in sheets, leaves drop earlier than most trees, and twigs come down after every gust of wind. It’s a tree that seems allergic to holding itself together. They also tend to attract diseases like anthracnose, which causes leaf spots and defoliation. If you enjoy spending your weekends sweeping up bark and replacing bare patches in the lawn, then maybe. For most homeowners, it’s too much trouble.
8. Mulberry
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Mulberries are bird magnets, but not in a cute, chirpy way. Their fruit stains driveways, cars, and sidewalks, and the purple splatter is nearly impossible to scrub off. Birds eat the berries, then leave “reminders” on everything nearby. Some varieties don’t produce fruit, but they still grow aggressively and send up suckers all over the yard. You’ll spend more time pulling shoots than enjoying the shade. This one’s best left out of residential landscaping.
9. Tree of Heaven
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Despite the name, there’s nothing heavenly about this tree. It’s invasive, grows rapidly in poor soil, and produces a strong odor that many people find unpleasant. Once established, it’s hard to kill—cutting it down often encourages even more shoots to appear. It also spreads via aggressive roots and seed pods that blanket the ground. It’s been known to crack sidewalks and outcompete native plants. If you see one at the nursery, walk away.
10. Russian Olive
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Russian olives are drought-tolerant and hardy, but that’s part of the problem; they thrive where they shouldn’t. In many states, they’re considered invasive because they displace native plants and dominate open spaces. Once they get going, they’re hard to remove. They also have thorns and brittle branches, making them a poor choice for play areas or close to pathways. Although they’re tough survivors, they don’t play well with others.
11. Mimosa
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Mimosas bloom with fluffy pink or yellow blossoms and grow fast, but are fragile. The wood is weak and snaps easily in storms. They also drop a large number of seed pods, which litter the yard and sprout wherever they land. Worse, they’re prone to fusarium wilt, a disease that kills them off early and leaves you with a sad-looking stump. Their beauty is short-lived, and their mess is long-lasting.
12. Chinese Tallow
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Also called the popcorn tree, the Chinese tallow is another beauty with baggage. It spreads quickly, drops huge amounts of seeds, and outcompetes native trees. For this reason, some states have listed it as an invasive species. It also produces a waxy coating on its seeds, which can be toxic to livestock and pets. The fast growth might appeal to impatient homeowners, but it brings long-term consequences.
13. Leyland Cypress
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Leylands are often planted as privacy screens because they grow tall and dense in a short period. But they’re also prone to disease, especially when planted too close together. Their root systems are shallow, which means they fall easily in strong winds. They also grow so fast that they outpace their stability. What starts as a tidy hedge can quickly become a towering wall of maintenance. If one dies, the gap ruins the entire screen—and they’re expensive to replace.
14. Eucalyptus
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Eucalyptus trees grow quickly and shed constantly. Leaves, bark, branches—you name it, it drops. They’re also highly flammable, which makes them risky in fire-prone areas. The oil in the leaves can ignite easily, and the peeling bark adds fuel. Some species release chemicals that inhibit the growth of other plants. So you’re left with a tall, oily, messy tree surrounded by a bald patch of dirt. Looks great in the Australian outback. Less great next to your garage.
15. Box Elder
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Box elders are part of the maple family, but are its unruly cousin. Their wood is soft, their branches are brittle, and they attract boxelder bugs—those red and black insects that cover walls and windows by the hundreds. They grow quickly but sloppily, often developing multiple trunks and unstable canopies. Between the bugs, the breakage, and the poor structure, they rarely age gracefully. You can do better.
Consider Your Options
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Before planting any tree, look beyond the label at the garden center. Research how it behaves once mature, how much space it really needs, and what it might drop on your roof, yard, or driveway. A good tree adds beauty, shade, and value (and is likely native to the area). A bad one adds repair bills and regrets. The right choice starts with knowing the wrong ones.