New York Man Accused of Taking $5.7 Million From Friends in Fake Real Estate Deals
A New York man who promised friends and family big returns on real estate deals is accused of taking more than $5.7 million from investors. Federal prosecutors say the properties were never purchased, and much of the money went elsewhere.
Andrew Laub, 59, of Goldens Bridge, was arrested on November 10 and charged with wire fraud. His alleged victims included people who had known him for years, including one friend he had known since childhood.
Laub had presented himself as an experienced real estate developer with ties to a firm that managed more than $750 million in property assets. He offered investors a chance to make money by buying, fixing, and reselling homes in New York and other states.
Some were promised returns of 45% a year. Others were told they could earn thousands of dollars in just weeks. According to federal court records, Laub kept the money coming in with signed agreements, fake emails, and payments that made the deals appear real.
Friends With Money
One of Laub’s earliest investors was a Westchester County resident who gave him around $250,000 in 2020. The promised return was roughly 45% a year, with interest paid each month.
Those payments helped build confidence. The investor’s family members eventually joined in, providing millions more for supposed projects in Virginia, Texas, and Florida.
Rather than seeking large sums from strangers, Laub allegedly relied on relationships he had built over many years. He also claimed his own family had money in the deals.
According to the federal criminal complaint, he continued sending investment offers and signing agreements as the amount of money grew.
His claimed experience added another layer of credibility. The complaint describes his past ties to a real estate firm with more than $750 million in assets. That figure referred to the firm’s claimed property holdings, not Laub’s personal wealth.
Homes Never Bought
By May 2025, Laub was pitching a Bronx property to another acquaintance, a Connecticut resident he had known for about 12 years.
The offer called for each of them to invest $180,000 in a house that could supposedly be resold for a quick profit. Laub projected a $55,000 return for the investor in about 45 days.
The investor wired $180,000 on May 9. But property records reviewed by federal investigators showed that Laub never owned the house. Its last recorded sale had been to an unrelated buyer around 2006.
A similar offer followed in July, this time involving a Bedford, New York, home with a claimed purchase price of $1.1 million.
Laub emailed a childhood friend in Florida, offering a deal that promised $150,000 back for every $100,000 invested. The friend eventually wired approximately $325,000.
There was a serious problem with that deal, too. The home’s owner told investigators that Laub had visited the property several times but never made an offer to buy it.
A Call Changes Everything
On January 5, 2026, the Westchester investor recorded a phone conversation with Laub that became a key part of the federal case.
During the call, Laub allegedly admitted he had never put the family’s money into the real estate deals as promised. He also acknowledged using funds for personal expenses and creating fake emails that appeared to come from family members.
Bank records gave investigators another piece of the story. According to prosecutors, money from newer investors had been used to pay earlier investors, helping keep the operation going.
Some of the funds also went toward gambling and personal purchases. Prosecutors described the arrangement as a Ponzi-like scheme, where incoming money helped cover promises made to earlier investors.
The complaint identifies three investors or investor groups with combined alleged losses of $5,758,630. It does not specify exactly how much of that money went toward gambling.
Federal Charges Follow
The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York announced Laub’s arrest on November 10.
He appeared that afternoon before Chief U.S. Magistrate Judge Judith C. McCarthy in White Plains federal court.
In a statement, U.S. Attorney Jamie McDonald accused Laub of exploiting personal relationships to collect millions of dollars for investments that never took place.
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service investigated the case. Its New York division said the fake documents were a major part of how Laub allegedly convinced people to invest.
Laub faces one count of wire fraud, which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in federal prison. He has not been convicted, and the charge remains an accusation.
