Homeowner Refuses to Cut Down Mature Oak Tree for New Neighbor Who Doesn’t Want Leaves in Her Pool
Getting new neighbors can be stressful. Neighbors can have a major influence on how someone feels about their home, especially when they cause tension in the neighborhood.
Unfortunately for Reddit user u/Fancy_Season372, that’s exactly what happened when the house behind them was purchased by a new owner. Now, a decades-old oak tree is at the center of a dispute between the neighbors.
“I’ve lived in my house for going on 20-something years and have a beautiful, healthy, mature oak tree in my backyard,” the post to r/neighborsfromhell started. “This week she got my wife’s phone number from her realtor and asked if we would be open to a conversation about cutting down a tree in our yard.”
According to the OP, the tree does have branches hanging into the neighbor’s side of the yard. However, the Redditor says that they are worried about pruning the tree too aggressively because it could damage the mature oak. Not only that, but they say that they are pretty attached to the tree after living with it for 20 years and don’t really want to see it harmed or removed.
Neighbor Wants Oak Tree Removed Because Leaves Are Falling Into Her Pool
New neighbor wants to cut down tree in my yard
by
u/Fancy_Season372 in
neighborsfromhell
It sounds like the issue is that the branches of the tree are dropping leaves into the new owner’s pool, and she wants it cut down to avoid the mess. “We’ve had four different neighbors since buying this house and not one of them ever asked for this,” the post continued. “Sure it was inconvenient, but they mentioned the shade it provides in the summer outweighs the annoying falling leaves.”
The OP said they were hesitant to make any changes because they’d recently removed other trees from the property, and the arborist they used advised them against doing anything else until the yard had a chance to recover from all of the changes. The OP says that all of this was relayed to the neighbor, who later showed up on their doorstep to talk about it some more.
New Neighbor Plans to Rent Out the Property
The OP later provided additional context, including the fact that the new neighbor admitted to purchasing the property as an investment that she intended to rent out. Not only that, but she also told the couple that she was a lawyer during their first face-to-face encounter, saying that she didn’t want the situation to “get messy.”
The OP is now asking Reddit for advice since they are worried about just how sticky the situation could get.
Redditors Offer Advice on the Neighbor’s Tree Dispute
Several commenters pointed out that being a lawyer doesn’t automatically make someone a threat. “Just because she claims to be a lawyer doesn’t mean she practices law, especially Texas law,” one of the top-rated comments said. “Don’t touch your tree; send her a notarised letter stating you do not agree to trimming or removing any trees from your property. A lawyer will not charge much to write this for you; it’ll be worth it.”
Several other people brought up “tree law.” According to the Texas State Law Library, generally the ownership of a tree belongs to the person whose property the trunk is on. The website also says that while a neighbor may have the right to trim the tree back to the property line, they can face legal action if that pruning injures or kills the tree or other property in the process.
Given the OP’s concerns, consulting a legal expert before responding to the neighbor’s request may be the best course of action
