Florida Homeowners Pay Thousands for Unfinished Pools, Then Get Liens From Unpaid Subcontractors
Florida homeowners who paid tens of thousands of dollars for backyard swimming pools say they ended up spending far more than expected. Some were left with unfinished construction, while others faced liens from subcontractors who said they hadn’t been paid.
The complaints involve Naples-based Goliath CPS LLC and its owner, Terence Farrell. Customers in Cape Coral and Naples described projects that dragged on for months, leaving them to hire replacement contractors and cover unexpected expenses.
A November 16 investigation by WINK News found that the company and people associated with it faced more than $220,000 in civil judgments across Lee and Collier counties. Florida regulators also issued an order against Farrell in May 2026 over unlicensed contracting.
For the affected families, the problems went beyond delayed construction. Some had planned to enjoy their new pools during retirement, only to watch their savings disappear into projects that cost considerably more than promised.
A Retirement Drained
Cape Coral residents Jim and Tracy Dunnier moved from New York to Southwest Florida in 2019, hoping to build a quieter life while raising their two grandchildren.
According to WINK Investigates, the couple agreed to pay approximately $74,000 for a swimming pool, with construction expected to take six to nine months.
They paid Goliath CPS roughly $60,000 before becoming concerned about permitting delays. Tracy Dunnier said Farrell eventually provided a permit application bearing another company’s credentials and the couple’s property information.
Cape Coral Code Enforcement subsequently stopped construction because the project lacked valid permits and a licensed contractor. The homeowners also received a $305 fine.
The Dunniers eventually hired an attorney and another contractor, spending approximately $70,000 more to finish the pool. Their total costs approached twice the original quote.
“This was our retirement,” Jim Dunnier told WINK.
More Bills Arrive
Other homeowners described similar financial problems.
Naples resident Matt Simanski hired Goliath CPS in June 2025 and provided canceled checks showing payments exceeding $100,000. He told WINK that subcontractors subsequently placed liens against his home because they hadn’t received payment.
Simanski also reported spending approximately $40,000 correcting construction mistakes, replacing missing equipment, and addressing staining from well water.
Another Naples homeowner, Bob Colette, agreed to a $105,000 pool project in 2024. After lengthy permitting delays and limited construction, Colette said communication with Farrell ended in June 2025.
He eventually hired a subcontractor directly to complete the job. His final expenditure reached approximately $150,000, roughly $45,000 above the original estimate.
Paying Twice
Florida law helps explain why homeowners can face additional bills even after paying their builder.
The Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation warns that unpaid subcontractors and suppliers may pursue construction liens against the properties where they worked, even when homeowners have already paid the main contractor.
Under Florida Statutes Section 713.06, qualifying subcontractors and suppliers have specific notice requirements before enforcing certain lien rights. Homeowners can reduce their exposure by obtaining appropriate lien releases as payments are made.
The state’s consumer guidance also recommends checking subcontractor payments before making a final payment. Without these protections, homeowners risk paying twice for the same improvements.
Judgments Pile Up
WINK identified three default civil judgments totaling approximately $221,695 against Goliath CPS and, in some cases, Farrell and former business associate Britney Marshall.
The largest involved a $172,500 judgment awarded to Tropical Maintenance of Southwest Florida for unpaid construction-related work. Two additional Collier County judgments involved SCP Distributors and Foundation Building Materials.
Florida corporate filings independently identify Farrell as Goliath CPS’s registered agent and manager.
WINK reported that a Lee County judge also pursued enforcement proceedings after the company failed to provide court-ordered financial disclosures. A potential bodily attachment was discussed, although an actual arrest was not independently confirmed.
The station reported unsuccessful attempts to contact Farrell and Marshall for comment. Meanwhile, subcontractor Nevin McLaren said he remained owed more than $4,000 but chose not to place liens against homeowners who had already suffered financial losses.
