flooded yard.

Homeowner Wins $200,000 Over Flooded Yard, but HOA Files for Bankruptcy Instead of Paying

An Alabama homeowner won a $200,000 jury verdict after years of stormwater runoff allegedly damaged his property. Four years later, he was still fighting over the drainage problem and trying to collect the remaining judgment.

William Carpenter’s dispute began in 2018, when he said water from the neighboring Crown Pointe subdivision in Mobile County began flowing onto his land. He eventually sued the homeowners’ association and several property owners, arguing that the subdivision’s drainage system was responsible.

A jury sided with Carpenter in April 2022, but the victory brought little closure. The association struggled to pay the judgment, filed for bankruptcy, and later created a second HOA. Meanwhile, Carpenter maintained that the drainage problems continued.

His efforts eventually led to another lawsuit involving owners and residents of all 21 lots in the subdivision. On November 13, 2026, the Alabama Supreme Court issued a decision that left much of the dispute unresolved.

A Victory Without a Fix

According to Alabama Supreme Court records, Carpenter’s property sits downhill from a drainage easement running behind four Crown Pointe homes. He alleged that stormwater was being directed onto his land.

Carpenter sued the HOA and four neighboring property owners in July 2020. Three owners settled before trial, paying a combined $84,000, while the fourth received a judgment in his favor.

In April 2022, a jury awarded Carpenter $200,000 against the HOA. After accounting for the settlements, $116,000 remained, with the recorded judgment totaling $126,504.64, including costs.

But the drainage problem reportedly continued. Minutes from an August 2022 HOA board meeting acknowledged that repairs were still necessary.

“We are still going to have to fix the problem of water onto Mr. Carpenter’s property,” the minutes stated.

The HOA subsequently arranged drainage work funded partly through a special assessment on the subdivision’s 21 lots. Carpenter alleged that the work was completed in March 2023 but failed to resolve the runoff.

The HOA Files for Bankruptcy

Collecting the judgment proved difficult, too. In August 2022, Carpenter recovered just $1,516.18 through garnishment of the HOA’s bank account.

According to his later lawsuit, board members subsequently opened another bank account in their own names and directed homeowners to send their dues there instead.

Carpenter alleged that the arrangement was intended to keep money out of his reach. That accusation remains disputed and has not been resolved by the Alabama Supreme Court.

In June 2023, the HOA filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Two months later, its board voted to create another organization, Crown Pointe West Homeowners’ Association, and residents were eventually instructed to send payments to the new association.

The bankruptcy raised questions about whether the original HOA was attempting to escape its financial obligations.

In a March 2024 court order, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Henry Callaway noted that Carpenter’s judgment was the association’s only listed debt and questioned the bankruptcy’s purpose.

The bankruptcy trustee attempted to collect the judgment through a special assessment on homeowners. However, the judge ruled in May 2024 that the HOA’s governing documents did not authorize assessments to pay legal judgments.

The bankruptcy case was dismissed in July 2024.

All 21 Lots Drawn Into the Dispute

With the drainage problem allegedly continuing, Carpenter filed another lawsuit in August 2024.

This time, he named both homeowners’ associations and owners and residents associated with all 21 lots in Crown Pointe.

He argued that homeowners shared responsibility for maintaining the drainage easement and alleged that some defendants had taken steps to avoid paying the earlier judgment.

Several homeowners disputed those claims, arguing that they did not own the easement as Carpenter alleged and had done nothing to cause the runoff.

The Mobile Circuit Court dismissed the claims against homeowners who were not serving on either HOA board. Claims against the original association and six board members remained pending, while default judgments had also been entered against the newer Crown Pointe West HOA.

Carpenter appealed the dismissals, hoping to bring the other homeowners back into the case.

Four Years Later, Still No Resolution

On November 13, 2026, the Alabama Supreme Court dismissed Carpenter’s appeal without deciding whether the other homeowners could be held responsible.

The justices concluded that the appeal was premature because important questions remained unresolved in the lower court, including who was responsible for the drainage easement and whether the defendants’ actions caused further damage.

Those findings could affect whether the dismissed homeowners should face liability, so the Supreme Court declined to intervene before the remaining claims were resolved.

The decision leaves Carpenter’s dispute far from finished.

As of the ruling, claims against the original HOA and six board members remained pending in Mobile Circuit Court. The opinion did not establish whether the drainage problem had been corrected or how much of the outstanding judgment Carpenter had collected.

For a homeowner who won a $200,000 verdict back in 2022, the latest ruling means the fight over the water flowing onto his property is still not over.

Author

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *