California Couple Dies at Friend’s Home, Lawsuit Claims Deadly Gas Went Undetected
A California couple who died while staying at a friend’s home had called for emergency help just hours earlier. Now, their three children are suing the homeowners and a water heater company, claiming a deadly gas leak went unnoticed even after paramedics arrived.
John “Jay” Ruskey, 53, and his wife Kristen, 49, were spending the night in Cambria after attending a birthday party on February 7, 2026. The Goleta farmers were well known for growing coffee and rare fruit in Southern California.
By the next morning, both had died from carbon monoxide poisoning. Investigators later found that a smoke and carbon monoxide detector in their bedroom had been disconnected, leaving them without a working alarm in the room.
The wrongful-death lawsuit, filed October 26, names water heater manufacturer Navien and homeowners Ben and Robin Korman. It claims a faulty exhaust vent allowed carbon monoxide to enter the couple’s bedroom and that the homeowners failed to protect their guests.
A Warning Missed
Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.
According to reporting by the Santa Barbara Independent, about 50 to 60 guests attended the birthday party. The Ruskeys stayed overnight in a guest bedroom next to the laundry room, where a tankless water heater was installed.
The complaint claims that the heater’s exhaust system had failed. As the heater ran to supply hot water, carbon monoxide allegedly escaped into the laundry room and passed through a connecting doorway into the bedroom.
Around 4:34 a.m., Kristen called 911 because her husband was vomiting and showing signs of a possible seizure. Guests had also heard him screaming. When paramedics arrived, Kristen told them Jay had eaten chocolate containing psychedelic mushrooms and might be having a bad reaction.
Paramedics recommended that Jay go to the hospital, but he declined treatment. The couple returned to their bedroom, unaware of the danger described in the lawsuit.
Guests checked on them around 9:30 a.m. Kristen was lying unresponsive on the laundry room floor, while Jay was found in bed without a pulse. Neither could be revived.
The Disconnected Alarm
The San Luis Obispo County coroner’s findings, reported by KSBY in March, confirmed that Jay died from the toxic effects of carbon monoxide. Kristen’s cause of death included carbon monoxide and ethanol. Both deaths were ruled accidental.
Detectives found a combination smoke and carbon monoxide detector in the room, but its electrical wiring had been disconnected. The sheriff’s office reported no signs of criminal activity.
The lawsuit claims no alarm sounded and nobody tested the air, shut down the water heater, or opened the rooms to clear the gas during the earlier emergency response. Those claims form part of the family’s case against the homeowners and manufacturer.
Previous Safety Recalls
Navien has faced carbon monoxide concerns before. In December 2011, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission announced a recall of approximately 13,000 Navien tankless water heaters because their vent collars could separate and allow carbon monoxide to escape.
Another recall in December 2018 covered about 3,400 water heaters and boilers. That problem involved components used to convert the equipment from natural gas to propane, which could lead to excessive carbon monoxide production.
Neither recall has been shown to involve the particular water heater at the Cambria property. However, the children’s lawsuit cites Navien’s past safety problems and other fatal poisoning cases to support its claims against the company.
Three Children Left Behind
Jay and Kristen helped establish California-grown coffee through Good Land Organics and Frinj Coffee. Their work supported dozens of coffee farms across Southern California.
Their three children were not at the Cambria party. The lawsuit seeks compensation for the loss of their parents, including the care and support they would have received while growing up.
Attorney David C. Shay, representing the family, told the Santa Barbara Independent that his team was focused on establishing the facts and seeking accountability. He also urged homeowners to install and regularly test carbon monoxide detectors.
The civil case seeks product liability damages from Navien and premises liability damages from the Kormans. The claims against the company and homeowners remain allegations, and their legal responsibility has not been established.
