Father Begged Police to Check on His 2 Young Daughters Before Their Deaths, Now He’s Taking Sheriff to Court
A grieving South Carolina father has filed a petition for a Writ of Mandamus against the Charleston County Sheriff’s Office. A copy of the petition was published on Scribd, and it shows that Zachary Deacon is asking a judge to compel Carl Ritchie (sheriff of Charleston County, South Carolina) to share more information about the death of his daughters.
The court documents, which were filed with the Court of Common Pleas for the Ninth Judicial Circuit, show that Deacon is using the Victims’ Bill of Rights to request information about the circumstances leading up to the deaths of his two daughters. Information he is seeking includes 911 recordings, dispatch logs, investigative records and body-camera footage.
The girls, who are only identified by their initials, were found deceased in their mother’s home on Sept. 29, 2026. Deacon and other family members had contacted the sheriff’s office to express concerns about the children, ages two and 15 months, leading up to their deaths.
Deacon was eventually charged with harassment as a result of the repeated calls and continued contact, but the charges were later dropped. Please note that the details of this case could be triggering for some.
The Father is Suing for More Information
According to a statement shared on behalf of Deacon and his family, the bereaved father says he is upset over a lack of information from Ritchie. “The Sheriff has held a press conference. He has gone on TV. He put video of the girls on the news the day after their funeral without telling Zack,” the statement posted to Facebook by the Law Offices of Gedney M. Howe, IV said. “But the file? ‘Still being assembled.’ ‘Has to be redacted first.’ ‘Not sure what we can share.'”
The statement also claimed that Deacon not only asked for help for his daughters, but that he “begged for seven weeks” before being arrested himself. Now, he and his family are looking for answers to several questions surrounding the death of the two girls, including who put an end to the requested welfare checks, why nobody checked on the children after a call related to a concerning social media post, and more.
The Mother of the Two Girls Has Been Charged
Deacon claims that he repeatedly contacted the sheriff’s office during August and September over concerns about his ex-girlfriend Justine May’s treatment of the girls. According to ABC News 4, both girls were in their mother’s care when their bodies were found.
The sheriff’s office was there on a welfare check around 1:17 p.m. when the girls were found. May was later arrested in connection with the deaths and charged with homicide. The final welfare check was one of 26 times that the sheriff’s office was reportedly called since Dec. 2021, with half of the calls taking place after Sept. 8, 2026.
In the weeks leading up to their deaths, May reportedly posted screenshots and detailed information about people who had reached out to her about her daughters’ well-being, including a claim that May’s own mother called the police to tell them that the mother of two was “Nyx, the goddess of night.”
May was taken into custody and charged in connection with the deaths of her daughters, who were later determined to have died from dehydration and starvation associated with neglect. They were believed to have been dead for several days before they were found.
People Shared Their Sympathies With the Family
Live 5 News posted about the story on Facebook, where people went to the comments to share their sympathies. “It’s not going to bring his babies back, but he absolutely should sue,” one person wrote in part. “They still haven’t dropped the harassment charges from his repeated calls to 911 to try to get help for his girls.”
“It’s not about the money, but an example needs to be set,” another person added. “Our children are important; they matter. If CPS was called 35 times within two months, that was a clear sign something is wrong. This case is so heartbreaking.”
May’s case is still ongoing, and her preliminary hearing is scheduled for next month.
