A mysterious and dimly lit hallway leading to a closed door, creating an eerie atmosphere.

Neighbor Accused of Harassing Children for Years Faces Court Order and $550K Lawsuit

A Manhattan family says life in their Upper East Side apartment has become so stressful that even a birthday celebration ended with a police visit. The trouble, according to a lawsuit, comes from a downstairs neighbor who has spent years complaining about children living above her.

Tara and Riad Abrahams moved into 85 East End Avenue with their three children in November 2025. They hoped to make the four-bedroom apartment their home, but soon began dealing with angry outbursts, loud banging, and repeated complaints to police, according to court papers.

Their landlord says the family is far from alone. Three other households reportedly left the same apartment after years of similar problems involving Anne Stockton, a 72-year-old tenant who has lived one floor below since 1992.

Now the dispute has reached Manhattan Supreme Court. Building owner 85 East End Owner LLC filed a lawsuit in October, seeking at least $550,000 in damages and legal fees. A judge has also issued a temporary order restricting Stockton’s conduct toward the family upstairs.

A Birthday Interrupted

The Abrahams family says Stockton has made ordinary activities at home difficult. Even quiet afternoons have led to complaints, while their children have grown afraid of being alone in the apartment.

According to the court filings, Stockton has shouted insults, used offensive language, and repeatedly struck her ceiling with what sounds like a heavy pipe. The family claims the banging can continue for hours.

Their eldest daughter’s 16th birthday brought another confrontation in October. While the family opened presents around the dinner table, Stockton allegedly began shouting and called police.

It was not the first visit. The lawsuit says Stockton has contacted police about the family at least 10 times since they moved in, although building staff has found no evidence to support her noise complaints.

The couple says the strain has affected all three children. Their youngest son, who is 10, has struggled to understand why their neighbor seems so angry with them.

“My 10-year-old son now constantly asks me, ‘What did we do wrong? Why does the lady on the 10th floor hate us?'” Riad Abrahams wrote in a sworn statement cited by the New York Post.

Years of Complaints

Long before the Abrahams family arrived, other parents were raising similar concerns.

Jennifer Gaydos Stephan lived upstairs with her then-husband, Scott Hartman, and their four children beginning in 2013. She told the Post that Stockton regularly struck her ceiling with a broom and left notes demanding that the children be quiet.

The trouble eventually spread beyond the apartments. In a 2014 email included in the lawsuit, Hartman claimed Stockton had cornered two of his children in an elevator and threatened to discipline them herself.

After two years, the family broke its lease and moved.

The next resident, Mitch Jacaruso, reported another elevator confrontation in 2017. Stockton allegedly yelled at his children, then ages 11 and 8, calling them animals and threatening to sue. The lawsuit says the encounter helped push Jacaruso to leave.

Mark Weiss moved in afterward, but having his children visit only part of the time did little to ease the problems. In 2019, he complained that ceiling banging frightened his daughter and that Stockton had come to his apartment.

Weiss remained until 2024. By the time the Abrahams family arrived the following year, the landlord says three families had already left after dealing with Stockton’s behavior.

A Costly Dispute

The building itself is no ordinary apartment complex. New York City property assessment records identify 85 East End Owner LLC as the owner of the 15-story building, which overlooks the East River.

While four-bedroom apartments there can rent for thousands of dollars each month, Stockton pays about $1,775 for her rent-stabilized apartment, according to the Post.

The landlord also claims she owes nearly $88,000 in unpaid rent. A ledger cited in the lawsuit shows irregular payments since 2018, with $24,000 in state rental assistance received in spring 2026. Stockton disputes the claimed balance.

The dispute is not limited to money. The landlord is asking the court to address what it describes as years of harassment against families living above her.

Court records show the case was filed October 26, with additional sworn statements submitted the following day. On October 30, Justice Francis A. Kahn III signed an order restricting unreasonable noise, threats, intimidation, and other threatening behavior toward the upstairs residents.

Stockton did not respond to the Post’s requests for comment. The allegations remain contested, and the temporary order is not a final ruling on the lawsuit.

The official docket lists the nuisance case as active. Records supplied through November 6 show additional affidavits documenting service of the court papers and order.

Author

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *