North Carolina Man Refuses to Dim 60,000 Christmas Lights Despite HOA Fight
A North Carolina man’s Christmas light show has become the center of a fight with his homeowners association. After spending more than $70,000 on decorations, Neil Heuer is now suing the HOA over rules that could affect his annual display.
Heuer lives in Aero Plantation, a private neighborhood in Waxhaw. For five years, he has decorated his property with thousands of lights, moving figures, and music. His Christmas show alone has featured more than 60,000 lights.
Families have driven through the neighborhood to watch, but the extra visitors have upset some residents. The HOA raised concerns about traffic and safety, leading to a hearing in September and a lawsuit filed the following month.
Now, with Christmas approaching, Heuer is preparing another display. The association has proposed new rules covering outdoor lights and activities that attract visitors, but homeowners are not expected to vote on those changes until January 2027.
Quite the Show
Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.
A Queen City News report from an earlier stage of the dispute shows how much work Heuer puts into the display. The lights flash in time with a playlist of 15 Christmas songs, covering much of his large home and yard.
Heuer told the station that visitors typically stop for about three minutes before leaving. Several people interviewed while watching the show praised his work and questioned why anyone would object.
The homeowner has also used his interest in technology to build the displays, which started as entertainment for his children. His High Flying Lights website provides information about the shows and encourages visitors to support a local charity.
Still, Aero Plantation is a private community, and its HOA maintains the roads. The neighborhood is not gated, but the association has argued that large numbers of outside visitors create problems for residents.
Beyond The Decorations
Heuer believes the complaints are tied to an older disagreement with the HOA board. In an interview with Realtor.com, he explained that tensions began when he questioned plans to spend neighborhood funds on golf course improvements.
He later started an anonymous newsletter that criticized HOA decisions. Once residents discovered he was behind it, Heuer says his relationship with the board grew worse.
The association has not confirmed that account. Its stated objections have focused on the holiday displays and the traffic they attract.
In August 2026, HOA attorney Benjamin Karb sent Heuer a letter raising concerns about outsiders entering the subdivision. The association claimed the activity could violate neighborhood rules against nuisances.
A hearing followed in September. The board found that Heuer had violated restrictions involving exterior lighting and sign sizes. However, it did not find a violation concerning visitors at that time. Questions about parking and exterior changes remained unresolved.
Taking It To Court
Rather than accept the board’s findings, Heuer filed a lawsuit in Union County Superior Court in early October. He argues that the HOA exceeded its authority and did not follow proper procedures when enforcing restrictions.
The association has since adopted new parking rules that hold homeowners responsible when activities on their property bring outside traffic onto private roads.
Two proposed amendments could impose further limits. One addresses attractions that regularly bring nonresidents into the neighborhood. The other covers flashing, pulsing, and high-intensity outdoor lighting.
HOA President David Arno told Realtor.com that the association would respond to Heuer’s lawsuit through the legal process. He also said members have the right to decide whether to approve changes to the community’s governing rules.
For now, Heuer intends to continue his Christmas tradition. The proposed amendments are scheduled for a vote at the end of January, after the holiday season.
Although he plans to keep decorating, Heuer does not intend to stay in Aero Plantation permanently. He told Realtor.com that his family plans to move after his youngest daughter finishes high school, and that his next neighborhood will not have an HOA.
