HOA driveway fines.

HOA Fines Homeowner $150 for Trailer, but President Has Had Boat in His Driveway Since Spring

Living in a homeowners association (HOA) can mean having to deal with a lot of different rules. All of these rules and regulations can be hard to keep track of, and some people find themselves unintentionally violating them. 

But what happens when someone realizes that the rules aren’t being enforced equally for everyone? That’s the subject of a recent r/AmITheKaren post on Reddit, where Redditor u/According_Leg_374 posted a question about her HOA experience, explaining how her community has a strict 48-hour rule prohibiting trailers or boats in driveways.

“We tore the old deck off the back of the house in October, and my husband borrowed a utility trailer to haul the lumber to the dump, and it sat in our driveway between loads for about three weeks,” she wrote. “The violation notice came in the mail at the end of October. It was $150, and they literally attached a photo of my own driveway taken from the street. Fine, that’s the rule. I had the trailer back at my husband’s cousin’s place that same afternoon.”

However, the fine became an issue when the OP realized that the HOA president had a boat sitting on a trailer in his driveway, which had been there since spring. The trouble began when the OP asked the HOA to start enforcing the rules equally for everyone, prompting backlash from the president himself.

The Homeowner Wanted to Know if She Was in the Wrong

AITK for asking our HOA why my trailer got fined when the president has had a boat out since spring?
by
u/According_Leg_374 in
AmITheKaren


After the homeowner realized just how long the president had been keeping the boat in his driveway, she reached out to the HOA to see if any other driveway fines had been issued.

“The secretary wrote back that each violation is handled individually and that my fine was due by the end of the month,” the post continued. “So, I replied with 3 photos of the corner driveway taken a week apart with the dates on them. I said I wasn’t asking anybody to fine him; I wanted the same rule to apply to his house. He answered that one himself and said the boat is actively in use and that I was making this personal.

Things only deteriorated from there. The OP says that the president wrote a column in the November newsletter about the incident. “There’s a paragraph in it about a homeowner on our street who got cited for a trailer and has been demanding to audit her neighbors instead of taking responsibility,” she wrote. “My name isn’t in it anywhere. He put in the street and the trailer, and there’s only 11 houses on this street, so everybody knew who he meant.”

The OP closed her post by saying that the fine doubles if she doesn’t pay it by the end of the month. Her husband wants to put the trailer back until someone fines the president, but she thinks that’s exactly what he wants. However, she doesn’t want to pay the fine if she’s the only one on the street who has to follow the rules. “AITK,” she asked. 

Redditors Gave Her Lots of Advice

There was no shortage of advice from Redditors. “If active use is the rule, as he has said, they will reverse the fine because your thing was also in active use,” one person wrote. “You were actively building something and removing the debris. The rule is obviously for people leaving trailers they’re not using for a long time.”

“Yes indeed. Drive it around the block once a day so it’s clearly being actively used,” another person added.

However, there were those who believed that the OP got what she deserved. “I think you missed a part where they chose to live in an HOA despite being a grown adult; it’s a given that they’re a ‘karen*/a–hole,'” they wrote.

While the OP didn’t update the post with how she planned to proceed with the fine, it looks like she received plenty of options if she wants to continue to push back. 

Author

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *