money 100 bill.

Florida Property Owner Wins $40K After Telecom Company Buries Cables Outside Permitted Area

A Miami property owner won $40,000 after a telecommunications company buried fiber-optic cables outside an area it had permission to use. But even after proving the company had crossed the line, the owner couldn’t force them to remove the cables.

The dispute began when Crown Castle carried out underground work on land owned by RJ’s International Trading. The company already had access to part of the property, but the new cables went beyond the approved area.

RJ’s took the matter to court and won damages. The property owner also wanted the cables dug back up, but that request was denied. What started as a dispute over underground wiring turned into a legal battle lasting several years.

Now, the Florida Supreme Court has weighed in. Its October 29, 2026, ruling dealt with another part of the fight: whether Crown Castle should have to pay the property owner’s attorney’s fees.

Digging Too Far

Embedded media follows; please allow a moment to load.

In February 2020, Crown Castle Fiber installed cables beneath a property in Miami. According to federal court records, the work went ahead without the property owner’s knowledge or consent.

The installation wasn’t supposed to be a problem. A property agreement dating back to the 1990s allowed telecommunications equipment and other utilities in a limited area. Over time, those access rights passed to other companies, including Crown Castle South.

But the new cables extended beyond that area. Crown Castle Fiber, which carried out the work, mistakenly believed the installation followed the agreement. RJ’s objected after learning where the cables had been buried.

Attempts to settle the disagreement failed. In December 2020, RJ’s filed a lawsuit against Crown Castle South and AT&T, seeking damages and the removal of the cables. The case eventually went before a jury.

Money, Not Removal

A federal judge found Crown Castle South responsible for trespassing and breaking the property agreement. After a six-day trial, jurors awarded RJ’s $40,000 for trespass and another $1 for the broken agreement.

The court added $5,606.20 in interest, bringing those awards to $45,607.20. Jurors also declined to award extra damages meant to punish the company.

RJ’s had another goal beyond collecting money. It wanted the court to order the cables removed, even after winning the trespass case.

The judge initially approved removal but later withdrew that order. One problem was that Crown Castle Fiber, the company that actually installed the cables, wasn’t a defendant in the lawsuit.

There was also the money RJ’s had already received. The damages covered both past losses and harm the property owner could face in the future.

In April 2024, a federal appeals court upheld the decision not to require removal. The judges pointed out that RJ’s had received money for the continued presence of the cables rather than asking for damages to cover the cost of digging them up.

The Legal Bills

Winning the trespass case didn’t end the dispute. RJ’s also wanted Crown Castle to pay its attorney’s fees, relying on a promise written into the original property agreement.

That agreement said the losing side in a lawsuit to enforce its terms would pay the winner’s reasonable legal costs. The trouble was that neither RJ’s nor Crown Castle South had signed the agreement when it was first created.

RJ’s argued that the promise should still apply because both companies had taken over rights connected to the land. Crown Castle opposed the request, and a federal judge ruled against the property owner.

The dispute reached the Florida Supreme Court after federal appeals judges asked it to decide whether that old promise could bind later parties.

On October 29, 2026, the Florida Supreme Court ruled that it could not automatically carry over with the property. The justices found that paying legal fees was separate from the rules governing how the land could be used.

The court sent the case back to the federal appeals court for further proceedings. The decision left the earlier trespass award intact while rejecting RJ’s argument that the attorney-fee promise followed the land to later parties.

How much RJ’s attorneys’ fees amounted to was not disclosed in the court documents, making it unclear whether RJ came out ahead with his awarded amount.

Author

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *