Senior Wins Legal Battle After Spending Connecticut Winter Without Heat, Winning Over $10K
Karen Quinn spent last winter dealing with something no one—but especially not an 83-year-old tenant—should have to endure: an apartment without working heat.
Now she has won a legal fight over it. A judge has ordered Quinn’s landlord, Alpha Capital, to pay her more than $10,000.
Quinn lives at Bay Point Apartments in Niantic, Connecticut. The Day reports that Quinn went without working heat through the winter before taking the dispute to court, where a judge ordered Alpha Capital to pay her more than $10,000.
The judgment gives Quinn a concrete victory after months of complaints concerning conditions at the complex. It also comes as Bay Point tenants have increasingly pushed back publicly against their landlord over maintenance, rent and housing stability.
The Heat Went Out the Day After Christmas
Embedded media follows. Please allow a moment for it to load.
Niantic senior wins legal battle against landlord after not having heat all winter. https://t.co/gP9qel4oxB pic.twitter.com/mJLUHqlT71
— The Day (@thedayct) September 8, 2026
Quinn had already described the heating problems publicly before the court decision.
“Both winters, I had trouble with the electricity and the heating,” she said in July, as reported by the Connecticut Mirror. “This last winter, on Dec. 26, the heat went off completely.”
Connecticut law sets the following baseline: if a landlord is responsible for supplying heat, the dwelling must be capable of maintaining at least 65 degrees, according to the state Department of Consumer Protection.
Under Connecticut law, tenants can take certain steps when a landlord fails to provide an essential service such as heat. Depending on the circumstances, those remedies can include obtaining the service and deducting the reasonable cost from rent, securing temporary housing after 48 hours, or terminating the lease when the failure is willful.
Bay Point Tenants Have Been Speaking Up
Quinn’s case unfolded against a broader dispute between Alpha Capital and Bay Point residents. In public comments to the East Lyme Board of Selectmen, the Bay Point Tenants Union said it represented more than 40 households and raised concerns about rent increases and difficulty communicating with management.
Heating problems were also raised by other residents. After visiting Bay Point in April, state Rep. Nick Gauthier wrote that some tenants had gone weeks during the winter waiting for repairs to heat and leaking hot-water heaters, forcing them to rely on plug-in electric heaters.
The dispute also reached the state Capitol. In July, state Rep. Nick Menapace said he joined Gov. Ned Lamont, other lawmakers and Connecticut Tenants Union members to press Alpha Capital over tenant concerns, including heating problems and repairs at Bay Point.
Alpha Capital CEO Tyler Smith said in a statement published by the Connecticut Mirror that the company is “committed to providing safe, quality housing” and has spent millions renovating properties it acquired.
