The fireplace naturally becomes the center of attention during the holidays. Lights are low, gatherings last longer, and every detail around the mantel gets noticed. Some decorations feel festive anywhere else in the house but look oddly misplaced once they land on or inside the fireplace.
Here are five holiday decorating choices that tend to miss the mark, along with better ways to handle them so the fireplace stays inviting and balanced.
1. Oversized Inflatable Holiday Decorations
Image Credit: Melissa Herzog / Shutterstock.
This one seems obvious, but apparently people do it anyway. Inflatables belong outdoors or in wide-open family rooms. When placed near a fireplace, they crowd the mantel, block architectural details, and pull attention away from the hearth itself. A giant Santa or snowman can make even a large fireplace look smaller and awkwardly top-heavy.
Fireplaces work best with items that respect scale. Inflatable décor rarely does. Use smaller tabletop figures or a simple garland with subtle ornaments. Save inflatables for the yard where space works in their favor.
2. Artificial Trees on the Hearth
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Mini holiday trees seem harmless, but placing them directly on the hearth often feels forced. They block the opening, interrupt symmetry, and create a cluttered look, especially if the fireplace is not in use but still visible.
Trees need breathing room. Move small trees to either side of the fireplace on the floor, or place a single tree elsewhere, and keep the hearth clear.
3. Scented Candles in Heavy Clusters
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Holiday scents feel right for the season, but stacking multiple scented candles on a mantel creates visual and sensory overload. Different jar styles, labels, and colors fight for attention. If the fireplace is functional, heat exposure becomes another concern.
Less variety reads calmer and more intentional. Choose one or two unscented candles in similar holders. Add greenery or pinecones nearby for a seasonal nod without excess.
4. Flashing or Multicolor String Lights
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Blinking lights wrapped tightly around the mantel or firebox pull focus in the wrong way. They flatten the fireplace visually and often clash with the room’s existing lighting. Instead of warmth, the result feels busy and distracting.
Fireplaces benefit from steady light, not constant motion. Use warm white lights woven lightly through garland or greenery. Keep wiring hidden and spacing loose.
5. Holiday Signs with Loud Phrases
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
Seasonal signs with large text can overpower a fireplace fast. When the message is bold and the font heavy, the mantel turns into a billboard. This works against the fireplace’s role as a grounding element in the room.
Decor that shouts tends to date quickly. Swap signs for neutral artwork, mirrors, or simple wreaths that nod to the season without spelling it out.
Giving the Fireplace the Last Word This Holiday
Image Credit: Shutterstock.
A fireplace looks its best when holiday décor supports its shape and scale rather than fighting it. Step back and look at what the fireplace reflects and frames, not just what sits on it. If decorations block the opening, hide details, or pull attention upward too aggressively, it is time to edit.