15 Best-Tasting Tomatoes from the Garden to Your Kitchen

Tomatoes are the quintessential garden crop, celebrated for their vibrant flavors and versatility in the kitchen. Whether you’re preparing a fresh salad, whipping up salsa, or canning sauces, the right tomato variety can make all the difference.

Below, we’ve compiled 15 of the best-tasting tomatoes for gardens and kitchens. From classic heirlooms to sweet cherry tomatoes, discover your next must-grow favorite and learn how to care for them to ensure a bountiful harvest.

1. Brandywine 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Known for their robust, old-fashioned flavor, Brandywine tomatoes are often considered the gold standard of heirlooms. Their rich, sweet, and slightly tangy taste pairs perfectly with sandwiches and fresh salads. These fruits are large and beefy, often weighing up to 1 pound, with a smooth pink-red skin.

Growing Tips: Plant Brandywine tomatoes in full sun with well-draining soil enriched with compost or organic matter. Stake or cage the plants, as the large fruits can weigh down the stems. Regular watering and consistent moisture are best, but avoid overhead watering to prevent fungal issues.

2. Cherokee Purple 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Cherokee Purple tomatoes feature a deep purple skin with reddish undertones and a bold, smoky flavor that’s truly unforgettable. Their complex sweetness and juiciness make them excellent for caprese salads and fresh garden tastings.

Growing Tips: Provide plenty of sun and amend the soil with compost before planting. These plants may require staking due to their sprawling vines. Prune excess foliage to promote airflow, which reduces the risk of disease. Harvest once the fruits feel slightly soft.

3. San Marzano 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: San Marzano is a prized plum tomato known for its thick, meaty flesh and minimal seeds. The rich, slightly sweet flavor shines when cooked down into sauces, soups, or stews, making it a staple in Italian cooking.

Growing Tips: San Marzano tomatoes thrive in full sun with nutrient-rich, well-draining soil. Space plants around 2–3 feet apart to ensure they’re not competing for resources. Stake or trellis the vines for better support and easier harvesting.

4. Sungold 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Sungold tomatoes are small, golden-orange fruits bursting with sugary sweetness and a slight tang. Their candy-like flavor is incredibly popular for snacking, and they also add vibrancy to salads and pasta dishes.

Growing Tips: Plant Sungold tomatoes in a sunny spot with fertile, well-draining soil. Keep the soil moist but avoid water pooling near the roots. These indeterminate plants grow tall and full, so provide sturdy supports like cages or trellises.

5. Beefsteak 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Beefsteak tomatoes are large, meaty fruits that offer a classic, bold tomato taste. Their juicy flesh and mild acidity make them ideal for slicing onto burgers, sandwiches, or as a star of a tomato salad.

Growing Tips: Provide plenty of space, as Beefsteaks are large plants with sprawling vines. Use sturdy stakes or cages to support their size. Ensure consistent watering and deep feeding at least once a month with an organic tomato fertilizer to improve fruit quality.

6. Mortgage Lifter 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: This heirloom tomato is known for its smooth, sweet flavor with a hint of tanginess. Mortgage Lifter tomatoes are massive, often weighing 1–2 pounds, making them a great choice for slicing and fresh eating. 

Growing Tips: Like many heirlooms, Mortgage Lifter plants benefit from full sun and nutrient-dense soil. Use a high-quality, potassium-rich tomato fertilizer to boost fruit production and prevent blossom-end rot. Stake or cage the plants to keep the vines upright. 

7. Sweet 100 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: With their high sugar content, Sweet 100 tomatoes deliver one of the sweetest experiences you’ll find among cherry varieties. These bite-sized fruits are perfect for snacking straight from the vine or tossing into salads. 

Growing Tips: Sweet 100 plants are vigorous growers. Plant them in full sun, spacing them 2–3 feet apart to improve airflow. Regular pruning of suckers will direct the energy to fruit production, and staking is a must for their heavy yields. 

8. Black Krim 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Black Krim tomatoes are a sensory delight, with their smoky, tangy, and slightly salty flavor. The fruits feature a dark purple-red hue, both inside and out, and are a standout on charcuterie boards. 

Growing Tips: These tomatoes prefer a sunny, warm climate. Add organic compost to soil before planting and water consistently to keep the fruits from splitting. Harvest them as soon as they develop their signature dark color and feel slightly soft. 

9. Green Zebra 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: True to its name, Green Zebra tomatoes boast vibrant green skin with yellow stripes. They have a zesty, tangy flavor that’s perfect for bringing a citrusy kick to salsas and fresh salads. 

Growing Tips: Green Zebra tomatoes thrive in sunny locations with fertile, well-drained soil. Regular watering prevents cracking, but avoid waterlogging. Stake them for better air circulation, and harvest when the fruits turn a soft yellow-green. 

10. Roma 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Roma tomatoes, also known as plum tomatoes, have a mild, slightly sweet flavor with dense, fleshy interiors. They’re a favorite for cooking due to their low water content, making them perfect for sauces, pastes, and canning. 

Growing Tips: Roma plants grow well in full sun and prefer nutrient-rich soil. Fertilize regularly and prune back excess foliage to concentrate energy on fruiting. A medium-sized stake or cage will support their semi-determinate growth habit. 

11. Cherokee Green 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: A green-skinned variety with a sweet, rich flavor, Cherokee Green offers a unique twist for those who love heirlooms. These tomatoes have a juicy texture and are excellent for fresh eating or slicing into salads. 

Growing Tips: Cherokee Green thrives in similar conditions as its Cherokee siblings. Choose a sunny site, water deeply but infrequently, and mulch the base to maintain soil moisture. These plants grow tall, so sturdy staking is essential. 

12. Tiny Tim 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: As the name suggests, Tiny Tim tomatoes are petite cherry tomatoes with a sweet and juicy flavor. Their compact size makes them ideal for small gardens, container planting, or windowsill growing. 

Growing Tips: Tiny Tim tomatoes adapt well to pots or small spaces. Use a lightweight potting mix and water regularly to prevent drying out. Keep them in a location that receives at least 6 hours of sunlight daily. 

13. Costoluto Genovese 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: This Italian heirloom variety is prized for its ribbed, scalloped skin and rich, tangy flavor. Costoluto Genovese tomatoes are perfect for slicing or cooking into richly flavored sauces. 

Growing Tips: Plant them in a sunny area with fertile, well-draining soil. Regular watering is important, but ensure the soil dries out slightly between waterings. These indeterminate plants will also need trellising or caging for support. 

14. Amana Orange 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: Amana Orange tomatoes are large, bright orange fruits with a luscious, sweet, and citrus-like flavor. They’re a standout in salads and add vibrant color to any dish. 

Growing Tips: Amana Orange plants grow best in full sun with compost-enriched soil. Due to their large fruit size, tie the stems to strong stakes to avoid breakage. Ensure deep watering during dry spells to prevent blossom drop. 

15. Yellow Pear 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Flavor & Appearance: With its pear-like shape and sunny yellow hue, the Yellow Pear stands out in appearance and flavor. These tomatoes are mildly sweet and perfect for fresh eating or garnishing dishes. 

Growing Tips: Plant Yellow Pear tomatoes in full sun and provide plenty of room for their sprawling vines. A trellis or tomato cage will keep their growth under control and make harvesting easier. Pruning suckers can boost fruit yield. 

Tap into the Taste Potential 

Image Credit: Shutterstock.

Planting the right tomato varieties can transform your garden and elevate your cooking. Whether you’re a fan of sweet cherry tomatoes or smoky heirlooms, this list provides options that cater to every palate. By following the care tips for each variety, you’ll enjoy a thriving crop of delicious tomatoes all season long.