HOA’s Strict No-Fence Rule Backfires After Family Takes Dispute to Federal Court
One of the many benefits of living in a homeowners association (HOA) is the fact that these groups tend to ensure that communities have a uniform appearance, which can make some homeowners happy.
But maintaining that uniform look typically involves having some pretty hard-and-fast rules when it comes to what you can and cannot do with your property. For Wisconsin’s Nazcr Trac Property Owners Association Inc., that meant a strict “no-fence rule.”
Homeowners Lisa Newman and Michael Newman found themselves in court challenging that rule when they realized that they would need a backyard fence to keep their three children safe. According to vLex, the Newmans’ three children were diagnosed with autism and had a history of running away.
Ultimately, the family used the protections included in the Fair Housing Amendments Act to take their case to court, eventually receiving permission to install their fence. Here’s how it all went down.
The Children Were Diagnosed After the Family Bought the Property
The details of the case were provided in the court documents, where the Newmans say that they first asked about installing a fence in 2019, when they reached out to the HOA’s president, Kevin Burt. The parents said they were aware of the neighborhood’s fencing rules but asked what they could do to get permission to add a fence.
Months went by before the family learned through another neighbor that the board had denied their request. They attempted to get approval again in December 2020, citing the Fair Housing Amendments Act and providing a letter from the doctors involved with the children’s care, explaining why the fence was needed.
However, they (and the rest of the community) received a letter on Mar. 11, 2021, saying that the rules couldn’t be changed and that any exemption requests from residents would be denied.
A Judge Eventually Prohibited the HOA From Enforcing the No-Fence Rule
In May 2022, a judge issued a preliminary injunction, ruling that the Fair Housing Amendments Act superseded HOA rules. And while the HOA wasn’t required to remove the no-fence rule for the entire community, it needed to allow the family to install a fence so that the three children could safely enjoy their home.
The ruling appeared to remain in effect as of December 2024. While there aren’t any updates about whether the family has been able to install the fence yet—even with approval from the judge and the HOA, they would likely still need to obtain permits and follow local rules as well—it does seem like they were successful in securing permission to install the fence as soon as the time was right.
