Uncle Lets Nephew Live Rent-Free for Years, Then Nephew Tries to Take Ownership of His House
Living with extended family can be tricky. Not only does it sometimes force you to spend a long period of time in close quarters with people you may not be used to living with, but it can also create unusual dynamics.
However, the typical family drama that can come when someone overstays their welcome while crashing on the couch doesn’t appear to be anything compared to a recent court case that was published on Justia U.S. Law.
According to a Nov. 9 opinion from the Washington Court of Appeals, Jack and Leota Lyons owned a home in Tukwila. In 2011, they allowed their nephew Curtis Reep to move into the property. He did not pay rent, but the court documents show that he did make improvements and occasionally paid the water and electric utilities.
However, when Jack Lyons finally asked Reep to leave, he refused. Then, years later, Leota died, and the property was transferred to Jack, and he filed a lawsuit to establish rightful ownership of the property and to have Reep removed. But Reep had a counterargument and instead said that the property should be rightfully his through adverse possession.
Washington State Has Strict Adverse Possession Requirements
To qualify for adverse possession, the person claiming ownership of a property has to be able to prove that they’ve had exclusive control over the property, that the use of the property was public, that they physically occupied the property, and that the property was used in a way that an owner would use it without the owner’s legal permission. These requirements must all be met, and they must have existed for at least 10 years.
It sounds like the owner’s permission clause may prove to be a snag in Reep’s case, since he was originally allowed to move into the property with both his aunt’s and uncle’s permission. Additionally, Reep couldn’t prove that his aunt had withdrawn her permission before her death.
The Uncle Was Able to Retain the Property
Fortunately for Lyons, it seems like the Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court’s original decision, and he was able to keep legal ownership of his home. That means that Reep will have to eventually follow his uncle’s wishes and move out of the property … if that’s what he still wants.
Hopefully the loss of Leota and the court battle don’t prove to be too much for this family’s relationship, which was likely very strong back in 2011 when the aunt and uncle welcomed Reep into their home without having him sign a lease agreement or promise to pay rent.
